DBS bank in a sticky PR situation

DBS apparently have irked the gay community in Singapore because it’s CSR programme involved donating “a sum of their credit cardholders’ spending to support a children and learning project [to] Focus on the Family (FOTF)”. According to Trevvy.com, asia’s largest GBLT portal, FOTF is an anti gay organisation.

It reported that “FOTF is a local offshoot of the US organization of the same name, known for its strong anti-gay stance and programmes. FOTF regards homosexuality as a sinful moral choice and psychological problem. FOTF in Singapore promoted the activities of Liberty League, which describes queer sexuality with terms like “sexual brokenness” and “addiction and abuse”.”

From DBS’s point of view ”FOTF is a non religious and non political organisation. It is a voluntary welfare organisation supported and endorsed by the National Family Council and the Ministry of Community Development, Youth and Sports in Singapore.”

DBS spokesperson told Trevvy that,

“In line with DBS’ corporate social responsibility (CSR) efforts that are geared towards supporting children and learning, several welfare organisations that support similar causes were shortlisted. Focus on the Family (FOTF) is a voluntary welfare organisation (VWO) endorsed by the Ministry of Community Development, Youth and Sports. Further, the funds DBS contributes will be directed specifically towards building a new learning centre, scheduled to open next March, for children with various learning disabilities. As this ties in with the Bank’s CSR efforts to empower children through learning, we decided to pick FOTF as our beneficiary for credit card spend this Christmas. It is not the intention of the Bank to discriminate against any group through the choice of FOTF as our beneficiary.”

For full article click here.

One Trevvy member’s comment sums up the general sentiment on the issue. Other’s were less polite…

Lately DBS has been doing almost nothing right. Just look at the way they handle the DBS High Notes customers and then their Big Retrenchment Exercise without consultation with their union. They came accross as truly heartless. Labour Minister, Lim Swee Say, one of the most effective minister we have, is superb in handling the matter and giving them a good lecture.

I am utterly dissappointed with the higher management and Board of Directors of DBS. They are all for money without social conscience, totally insensitive to human concerns.

Any form of discrimination in today’s modern society context is disgusting and inexcusable, be it Race, Religion, Sex or Sexual Orientation. Only the weird, the idiotic and the people without conscience still discriminate openly or as a group. In the states, they called these group of people committing “organised crime” against humanity.

 

Lesson for us:

When picking a Corporate Social Responsibility programme, it is good to check how our target consumers will react to it. True enough we cant please everyone, but in the era of Web 2.0, we cant always be happy with focussing on the majority demographic/psychographic, we should also take note of which category of customers who are loudest. On the www, news travel faster than the speed of thought.

What you say can make you a PR disaster

It’s bad enough that Sarah Palin got so much flak for saying all the wrong things during the election campaign. It seems like she has yet to learn her lesson. In this interview, in an attempt to sound diplomatic she ends up winding her words into a tight noose. A walking PR disaster, indeed!

The questions were simple, yet with a convoluted explanation she makes herself look like she wants rape victims to bear their pregnancy just because being pro-life is better position to take… 

What can we learn from here:

1. First off, understand your position/angle and explore its weaknesses even before you go for the media interview. there is no position without flaw, so you might as well be prepared to admit it or have a defense for it instead of stumbling and looking foolish in front of the camera.

2. If you are caught off guard with a difficult question, pause to think. You don’t have to rattle off something just so that you have something to say. You are more likely come across as a sensible person by just admitting that the position you took does have its short comings.

 

3. Don’t rehearse your answers. Media usually will give the talking points before an interview. Prepare the points you will want to make for each issue/questions. Don’t ever memorize! You will only come across as very mechanical in the interview. Nobody likes to see a living robot.

4. You may not be as high profile as Palin, but saying all the wrong things because you can’t think on your feet will make you a disaster as big as Palin…

 

How do you know that what you said is really really silly? When others repeat it verbatim and it is actually funny.

All the buzz…. then it fizzles

Came across this blog post that nicely describes the danger of building up too much hype.

Nokia build up so much hype about its N97 before it was launched that media and blogosphere was abuzz with speculations. Then it was released and…..duh! nothing new there!

Here’s an excerpt:

Everyone was guessing about Nokia’s big announcement. All the heavyweight blog sites were weighing in with speculation. Some of the blogging elite even flew all the way to Barcelona for Nokia week just to find out what it was — but even they were sworn to secrecy….

…if you get everyone hyped about a launch (they had a massive countdown clock that countless sites had embedded in posts) is that you better have something spectacular to show when the time comes. Apple are masters of this tactic, but could Nokia pull the sme lever?

Umm, this is Nokia we’re talking about, remember. This is the company that is in a death spiral, shedding market share faster these days than Wall Street sheds investment bankers.

So at the appointed hour, Nokia unveiled the most underwhelming phone of the year:

The N97. It’s got a 16:9 screen, a slide out qwerty keyboard, a great camera, gps, accelerometer, 64Gb of memory, etc.

Whoop-ti-doo. We’ve seen all these things on so many other phones this year.

Talk about being late to the party!

Even the interface looks like they stole the “panels” concept from the Sony-Ericsson X1. And the “tactile touch screen” looks like a BlackBerry Storm ripoff.

Lesson we can learn:
If you must build up hype about your latest product. the reality of your product better live up to the heightened expectations, if not it is going to be received so poorly by the consumers are just going to react extremely negative to whatever good there is in your product.

Years to build credibility, one flight to tear it down

Friday, 21 Nov: Reuters/ST reported:

Chief executives (CEOs) from General Motors (GM), Ford Motor and Chrysler on Wednesday pleaded for US$25 billion (S$38.2 billion) in federal assistance to help pay their suppliers, workers and other expenses at a time when car sales have plunged along with a souring economy.

But sceptical lawmakers blasted them for flying private jets to Washington and failing to make personal sacrifices in exchange for federal assistance…..Even Democrats who said they were sympathetic to the carmakers’ plight expressed frustration that the executives used private jets, while professing ruthless cost-cutting measures…..

[Representative Brad Sherman, a California Democrat said] ’I also, though, must recognise that you’re in trouble mostly because of the economic downturn.’ Mr Sherman asked the CEOs if they were willing to sell their jets on Wednesday and fly back to Detroit on a commercial flight.

‘Let the record show no hands went up,’ he said.

 

Silly CEO’s! Going begging in private jets. Have they lost touch of reality? Would you give your pennies to a beggar in designer dress or even with just a handphone in hand? 

Lesson for us:

The CEO/director is the face of a company, what he does (or doesnt do) will affect the credibility of the company’s perception negatively and lower its branding. But you don’t need a PR genius to tell you that, do you?

After the subprime mortgage bubble comes The Brand Bubble

Here’s a vodcast of John Gerzema, Y&R Group chief insights officer, talking to Marketing Magazine on his book The Brand Bubble.

According to its website:

Customer surveys show that the number of high-performance value-creating brands is diminishing across the board. Yet at the same time, businesses and financial markets keep raising brand valuations. The result? A brand bubble that could erase large portions of intangible value in your company and send another shockwave through the global economy.

The Brand Bubble provides both analysis and solution.

The original post is here.

A winning brand goes straight to the heart

ST, 19 Nov, reported:

ELECTRONICS giant Hewlett-Packard (HP) decided to go straight for the heart, to stand out in an industry constantly looking to outdo rivals with whiz-bang gadgetry and high-tech specifications.The company has marketed the personal computer as an extension of the individual – to make it more than a machine.

‘The connect that we wanted to make was not based on benefits, but an emotional connect,’ said Mr Ajay Mohan, HP’s vice-president of marketing and small- and medium-sized businesses in the Asia-Pacific and Japan.’And the emotional connect that we wanted to establish was that the computer is an extension of yourself. It is something which you work with on a daily basis; this is where you put your ideas, this is how you operate. This is a very personal thing, and you do not look at it as an impersonal object.’

He was outlining HP’s successful three-year branding strategy to the audience at a marketing conference, the Brand Couture Congress, which opened at Suntec City yesterday.

HP got it right with their 3 year branding strategy “HP Personal Again”. Personally, I loved the campaign, it made PC fun. I particularly liked the TV ads that had famous people talking about their love of their PC but their face was never shown. How clever is that!

Here’s one with Pharrel the famous rapper:

 

 

The lesson here:

Don’t be to overly concerned with the visual branding of your product. Think about how your branding is connecting to your target consumers at an emotional level. After all, isn’t true that we are really emotional animals. A large percentage of buying decision is made based on emotions rather than logic. If not why else would you be wearing that watch on your wrist (since all watch does the same function of telling time)?

 

here’s the making of the TVC, if you are fascinated:

Just-In-Time Marketing – is your marketing plan flexible enough for it?

I came across this article recently and it made me realise that while business must take pains to map out marketing plans over months or years, it is always a good idea to keep it a little flexible to allow your business to capitalise maximally on any unexpected opportunities available. If your brand unexpectedly got a positive mention by a celebrity or a public figure that’s a powerful endorsement in itself! Don’t just sit there and smile at the free PR your brand is earning. Grab the emergency marketing kit and quickly launch a quick targeted campaign.

The story in New York Times mentioned that Michelle Obama went on Jay Leno show and promoted J. Crew brand that she was wearing. The company had no idea that she was going to do this. They only realised it when they saw her in one of their design during the teasers of the show.

What did they do? The marketing team went into action by 1. buying keywords for “Michelle Obama” on the search engines 2. setting up a page on their website promoting the outfit Mrs Obama wore 3. told their call centres how to handle enquiries…Phew! quite a lot of action in an instant!

The outcome: “J. Crew said it was pleased with the sales..”

You never know which public figure might be endorsing your brand. But if they do, are you ready to cash in on it?

Is it so difficult to apologise?

Yet another person writes in to Straits Times today about the lack of acknowledgement of accountability, but now it’s targeted at the government.

Town Council lost a few million dollars to bad investment by DBS and typically, they scrambled to offer logical explanations just to prove that it is a reasonable mistake on their part.

ST reported on 19 Nov:

EIGHT town councils (TC) run by the People’s Action Party have about $16 million invested in troubled structured products.The lion’s share of $12 million is from two TCs: Holland-Bukit Panjang ($8 million) and Pasir Ris-Punggol ($4 million).

The products include Minibonds linked to bankrupt US investment bank Lehman Brothers and the now worthless Merrill Lynch Jubilee Series 3 LinkEarner Notes.

Dr Teo Ho Pin, chairman of the Holland-Bukit Panjang TC as well as coordinating chairman for the 14 PAP town councils, disclosed this yesterday……The 14 TCs ‘do not have significant investments’ in the troubled products, he said. The $16 million is 0.8 per cent of all their funds available for investment. In Holland-Bukit Panjang, $8 million is invested in Minibonds and Jubilee notes. This works out to 6.7 per cent of its investible funds.

It has another $3 million in the potentially-troubling Pinnacle Notes Series 6 arranged by Morgan Stanley.

Pasir Ris-Punggol’s $4 million is 2.6 per cent while in the remaining six TCs, the amount for each is below 1 per cent.

Why can’t town council leaders be gracious and apologise?” asks Adrian Choo in his letter to ST. I second that!

As business owners, we can all learn something from this. An apology is worth more when given without demand.

Are you a business owner? Do you find it difficult to apologise when things go wrong?

What consumers need – A Humane company

Once again another Straits Times reader writes in to say that a little apology would be good for DBS’s reputation. When sh-t happens, apologies! Is that such a difficult thing to do? Do they need consultants to come in and teach them how to apologise like a person of integrity?Didn’t our parents teach us that when we were young?

It’s typical of corporates to pay big money for branding consultants to come up with all their Mission and Values that they so proudly display in a plague. But when things go wrong all the values are nothing but a poster on the wall. No one seems to understand how to put all those expensive values into action. (!!)

I checked DBS website for their list of Values. (Was half expecting it to be 3 values with initials, D,B and S, hahaha). But i didnt find any. So i went into the Community Relations and here’s what DBS thinks of itself:

Our commitment to the community

At DBS, we are committed to be a caring and responsible partner in the communities in which we live and work, by making a significant positive impact on improving the quality of life. We believe in helping people to be the best they can be, so that they, in turn, help themselves achieve their goals….

Well, where is the ‘significant positive impact’? A whole lot of hogwash?

Here is an excerpt from the forum letter (18 Nov’08):

The reputation of DBS Bank has taken a beating, far worse than in 1998. Investors have lost confidence in the bank, its services and its structured products. Some even commented that calls to the bank’s customer service hotline are met with rudeness and abruptness. It is time for damage control. It won’t hurt if DBS Bank apologises and takes a more humane approach to its customers.

Tip:When things go wrong and people get emotionally affected, all the logical explanations in the book will not help calm nerves. Just be human. You don’t need training for that.

Sorry – the hardest word to say?

Ah! Finally a Straits Times reader commented on the most obvious misgiving in the whole DBS High Notes saga – not a word of apology from the organisation. Of course, apology will not bring back the money lost, neither will it lessen the burden brought upon by the worry of a lifetime savings lost. But what it will do is show that DBS as an organisation is human. And like a human, it can and did make mistakes. It will “do the right thing”.

Here’s an excerpt of the letter:

BY SAYING that no one could have anticipated the collapse of Lehman Brothers, the remarks of the DBS Bank chairman (‘We’ve taken a hit but we will overcome’, Wednesday), coming soon after its CEO said the bank would do the ‘right’ thing (‘DBS will do the right thing: CEO’, last Saturday), hoped things would quickly go back to normal. What he is saying effectively is that the Lehman fiasco is unfortunate, no one saw it coming, so let us all charge everything to experience and start anew.This is like a doctor saying he never expected a patient with signs of high cholesterol and hypertension to expire any time soon.

As experienced money handlers, banks have on their payroll experts who do nothing but watch the financial market for signs that will point them to pots of gold and steer them clear of impending danger. In their quest for one-upmanship, fund managers and distributors do their rounds of due diligence, and cover their backs with all the legal ‘eventualities’ so nothing will go wrong….

….Unlike Japan, we do not expect chairmen or CEOs to resign just to make a wrong turn go away. If we cannot say sorry with some measure of grace, perhaps we should let more ‘right’ actions speak for themselves.

I have noticed that Singapore companies have a great difficulty in apologising when things go wrong. Companies may do everything logically expected of it – give good explanation, offer realistic solutions etc. But unfortunately, it has typically been very cold

So if you are business owner, one simple way to set yourself apart from all the other local companies, think about how you can be ‘more human’ towards your consumers. And maybe, just maybe, they will stick with you through thick and thin.

A company’s good reputation is not always build on good action, efficiency and brilliant customer service. It is also build on what happens when things go wrong. When sh-t hits the fan, it doesn’t automatically mean your reputation will go bust. How you respond and react to your customers concerns and needs will determine if your reputation will stay afloat or how deep it will sink. One simple way to make sure it doesnt sink into abysmal depths is an Apology.